Les Miserables
★★★☆☆
Synopsis: In 19th-century France, Jean Valjean, who for decades has been hunted by the ruthless policeman Javert after he breaks parole, agrees to care for factory worker Fantine's daughter, Cosette. The fateful decision changes their lives forever.
My Review: I expected to not love this movie...for the reasons stated
here. I thought I would probably enjoy it, but not love it. But I just
barely enjoyed it. If not for the second half it would have flopped for me altogether.
First of all, if you're going to make a film of a celebrated musical you must cast actors who can both act and sing. Both. One or the other is not enough. This is where this film makes its major mistake. Two words: Russell Crow.
We all know Russell Crow can act (I mean, A Beautiful Mind was amaze-pants), but I felt his acting suffered in this film. Javert is a very complex character and I felt Russell's portrayal was just sort of one-note and brutish. But the real offense was his singing.
Here's the main issue: there are exactly two pivotal characters in the musical version of Les Mis whose entire back story depends on just ONE song. Javert and Fantine. Everyone else has clues in dialog and plot that feed us the complexity of their character. But these two characters have one shot to sing their entire background and make us understand who they are, where they came from and how they got here. Let's just juxtapose these two performances.
Fantine does mention a daughter and a missing baby-daddy briefly in an early scene, but the rest of her story comes exclusively from the song I Dreamed a Dream. In this song alone we learn that she was young, had a romance and was utterly abandoned. We learn her virginity was taken during this brief, Summer, romance and that the events thereafter have crushed her spirit and put her in the hellish position she now finds herself in. And, oh man, did Anne Hathaway deliver. This 2-3 minute song is film transcendence. To hear the soundtrack is good, but the real magic comes from Anne's face. There is more than just a pasted on look of despair. Her face shows shame, regret, innocence, loss, anguish, disgust, self-loathing and much more. You can actually witness a lifetime of emotion on her face during this song. It was amazing.
Javert also has an opportunity to sing to us his entire back-story. The song Stars is a genius summary of the fatal flaw in Javert's logic that has made him into a justice-seeking madman. But you understand this madman. You can see where his drive comes from. See where a healthy respect for rules, the law and his belief in God's will has taken a small turn which later leads to a life of vengeful and misguided hunting of Jean Valjean. You can't fault Javert for acting in a way which he wholeheartedly believes is right. He is not acting out of malice or evil. This must all be communicated in one song and Russell Crow blew it. Not only was his singing horrid, but their was no conviction or emotion in his performance, an even graver sin. Sadly, Russell's singing wasn't as bad in the rest of the film, but no song was as important as this and he stunk it up. This may be the greatest miscast in movie history. It really dragged down a film that could have otherwise been very good.
Here's where you begin hating me: I was also underwhelmed by the performance given by Hugh Jackman. It wasn't horrible, but I don't think it's near Oscar-worthy either.
Having said that. Every other performance was spot on, if not amazing. You begin to hate Russel Crow even more when you realize that every bit-part revolutionist is a better singer than he is. And Eponine? Awesome. I was similarly impressed by Amanda Seyfried and Eddie Redmayne. Many reviewers took exception to Sacha Baron Cohen and Helena Bonham Carter as the Thénardiers, but I thought they did fine. These are probably the only two singing parts that really don't need to be perfectly executed.
Overall, I was not a fan of this film. People who adore the musical might really enjoy it, although I can't imagine anyone thinking Russell Crow was the right man for the part, but I was sadly disappointed and won't watch the film again.